Mystery Underwear-Carl Wesley Menswear
Mystery Underwear-Carl Wesley Menswear
Carl Wesley

Mystery Underwear

Regular price $15.00 Sale price $45.00 Unit price per
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Mystery Underwear.

Black Friday - Cyber Monday Sale: Mystery Underwear are $15 each through 11-29.

Many of these styles are made individually on demand using remaining fabrics. Please allow about 1-2 weeks assembly time. (Although the turnaround is usually faster!)

I will handpick and create surprise underwear for you from my fabric stash! Fabrics may include lace, prints, solids, mesh, or others and the styles could be anything from briefs to thongs to jockstraps. I really don't know what you will get until I go to my fabric stash. The fabrics cycle out regularly. If you order more than one Mystery Underwear I will make sure each item you get is different. -Wes <3 

 Sizing (Waist in Inches):

S 28" - 30"
M 32" - 34"
L 36" - 38"
XL 40" - 42"
2XL 44" - 46"

Important! Before ordering, please click here to double check my in-depth size guide. My sizing is more inclusive than comparable brands, so most guys need to SIZE DOWN from what they'd normally wear.

Fiber Content: Varies

Recommended Care: Varies

Shipping and Handling: All orders to the USA ship for a flat rate of $6. All international orders ship for a flat rate of $25. Orders 95+ ship free. Orders are fulfilled and shipped twice each week, usually Monday and Wednesday.

Share this Product

Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
Michael Seele
Mystery Underwear

I love my mystery underwear. It is like he read my mind. I got a teal classic jockstrap. I love both the color and style. Thank you.

Tim Becker
The surprise gift was a very nice pair of briefs.

Great pair of briefs. The workmanship is much better than national commerciap brands and the product is made in the USA.


Perfectly cut in all the right places, Just because this is a mystery pack doesn’t mean you’re lacking on quality you can tell how much detail goes into the final product and I will absolutely order again plus this is perfect for my own level of indecision!

Mystery Jockstraps

I ordered two of the mystery jocks and was completely satisfied with both of them! A great fabric and both well made! The pouch was big enough to support my well endowed package!

Sexy Underwear

Love the texture and feeling nice while wearing it. Love how it feels. Right size.